Supervisor, Claims - Casualty

Date: Nov 18, 2026

Location: North York - Toronto, ON (Hybr, CA Kitchener, ON, CA, N2G-1H6 Toronto, ON (Hybrid), CA Ottawa, ON (Hybrid), CA

Company: Wawanesa Insurance

Job ID: 10532 


Employment Type:
Existing Role

 

Work Environment: We offer a hybrid work environment that offers flexibility to our employees in balancing in-office (2 days per week OR 15 hours per week in a Wawanesa office) and remote work. 

 

Working Business Language: English. 
 

Salary: At Wawanesa, salary is only one component of a holistic, comprehensive and competitive offering that we provide to our employees. In addition to salary, full-time and part-time permanent employees are eligible for an annual bonus plan, leave of absence top-up programs and provided with generous vacation time, personal days, premium free benefits and pension plan. 
 

The salary offered for this role is determined with consideration to various factors, including but not limited to: your work location, local labour market conditions, external market salary data, internal pay equity and the knowledge, skills, experience and anticipated proficiency in the role. The salary offered is estimated to be within the following range: $100,000 -  $120,000. Candidates with salary expectations outside of the range are still encouraged to apply. 

 

About The Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company
Founded in 1896, The Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company is one of Canada’s largest mutual insurers, fully owned by its more than 1.8 million members. Headquartered in Winnipeg, Wawanesa is the parent company of WSI™, a specialty insurer delivering tailored solutions built around unique needs; Wawanesa Life, a provider of life insurance products; and Western Financial Group, a leading national distributor of personal and commercial insurance.

Wawanesa is committed to helping communities thrive in a changing world. The company invests more than $4 million annually in charitable initiatives, including $2.5 million each year to support people and communities on the front lines of climate change. Learn more at wawanesa.com.

 

We are currently seeking dedicated, driven, and enthusiastic individuals who thrive in a dynamic environment, embrace change, and are eager to gain diverse experience while advancing their careers as part of a growing team.

 

Job Overview

The Supervisor, Claims - Casualty contributes to Wawanesa’s goal of delivering an exceptional and consistent claims experience by providing leadership within the Claims department, with a focus on achieving key business objectives and member experience standards.

 

Job Responsibilities

  • Provide leadership and coordination to teams responsible for bodily injury claims, with particular attention to effectively managing the significant financial component associated with these types of claims.
  • Communicate proactively and in a timely manner with Claims teams to ensure members’ needs and inquiries are addressed promptly and professionally.
  • Lead teams responsible for handling bodily injury claims ranging from low to high complexity, including large losses.
  • Support employee development and performance management by providing effective feedback and coaching focused on building skills and competencies.
  • Encourage others to identify and adopt better approaches to solving problems and capitalizing on opportunities.
  • Guide the implementation and adoption of change within the workplace.
  • Achieve key performance objectives by organizing work, monitoring processes, and establishing priorities to maximize efficiency and productivity in accordance with company policies, procedures, and business plans.
  • Provide guidance and support to adjusters in reviewing and interpreting policy wording and coverage.
  • Conduct claim file reviews and support the team’s development and continuous improvement by establishing and monitoring individual and team performance goals.
  • Provide direction and coaching in areas such as liability determination, investigation, policy interpretation, settlement negotiations, and claim reserving.
  • Use reporting to monitor and respond to emerging trends related to reserves, claim severity, and the external environment.

Qualifications

  • Minimum of 7+ years casualty claims handling experience, in auto and general liability. 
  • 2 years of senior casualty claims handling.
  • ​Exceptional customer service skills demonstrating empathy and concern for member satisfaction. 
  • ​Excellent communication and interpersonal skills, with the ability to communicate at the right level for the audience. 
  • ​Strong leadership skills including the ability to positively motivate, coach and engage teams. 
  • ​Highly proficient time management and organizational skills with the ability to prioritize work in a fast paced, changing environment. 
  • ​Excellent knowledge of policy wordings in all lines of business, corporate guidelines, policies and procedures. 
  • ​Excellent investigative, negotiating and analytical skills. 
  • ​Post-secondary degree is preferred. 
  • ​Chartered Insurance Professional (CIP), or working towards designation and where required, dedicated to reach the proper licensing requirements.​ 


Diversity Equity, Inclusion & Belonging

At Wawanesa, we are committed to Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Belonging (DEIB) and believe that our strength lies in the diversity of our people – this is supported by having a representative workforce.

We welcome applications from all qualified candidates, including racialized persons, women, Indigenous Peoples, persons with disabilities, members of the 2SLGBTQIA+ community, gender-diverse and neurodiverse individuals, and anyone who can contribute to the further diversification of thought and ideas. 
 

We aim to ensure our recruitment process is accessible to all candidates. If you require accommodations during any stage of the recruitment process, please reach out in confidence to jobs@wawanesa.com.
 

All Wawanesa job applicants are subject to Wawanesa's Privacy Policy.

Please note that the recruitment process for this position may involve the use of AI tools to screen, assess, or select applicants. All final decisions are taken or reviewed by human recruiters and human hiring leaders in compliance with all applicable legislation.